What is my Keswick home worth?

The honest answer is that nobody can tell you from your address alone, and you should be wary of anyone who tries. A real number comes from the same place an appraiser and a Buyer's agent will both look: what comparable homes near you have actually sold for recently, adjusted for your lot, your condition, and what you've done to the place.

The reason that matters more in Georgina than most places is that the automated estimates on listing portals tend to smooth across all of York Region. York Region's median is pulled up hard by Markham, Vaughan and Richmond Hill, all of which sit above $1,085,000 year to date. Georgina's median is $785,000. An estimate built on the regional average will misprice a Keswick home, and it can miss in either direction depending on which comparables it grabbed.

I'll do the evaluation in writing, show you the specific sales it's based on, and explain the ones I threw out and why. It costs nothing and it doesn't commit you to listing with me.

Get a written home evaluation

Where Georgina sits in York Region

Georgina is its own market, not a discounted version of the towns south of it. Here's where the year-to-date medians actually sat through August 2026, across all home types:

  • Richmond Hill $1,111,995 · Aurora $1,102,500 · Vaughan $1,090,800 · Markham $1,085,000
  • Whitchurch-Stouffville $1,064,150 · East Gwillimbury $1,030,000 · Uxbridge $988,000
  • Newmarket $948,000 · Bradford $880,000 · Georgina $785,000

The volume figure is the one most owners here don't expect. Georgina closed 401 sales in the first eight months of 2026, against East Gwillimbury's 271 and Aurora's 438. By transaction count this is one of the busier markets in the region, not a quiet corner of it. There are more comparable sales to price against here than in several towns with far higher medians, which is genuinely useful when it comes to setting a number you can defend.

One caution worth stating plainly: these are municipality-wide medians covering every community in Georgina and every property type in it, from Lake Simcoe waterfront to inland subdivisions. Your street can sit well above or well below the town figure. Treat the number as context, not as your valuation.

Selling in Keswick and buying somewhere else

A fair number of the conversations I have start with someone who wants to move, not just sell. If that's you, the useful exercise is to run both sides of the trade at the same time, with real figures on each.

Moving south from Georgina generally costs more. The median gap to East Gwillimbury was about $245,000 through August, and to Aurora or Richmond Hill it's north of $315,000. Moving further out, or downsizing within Georgina, works the other way. None of that tells you what your own move will cost, because the mix of what's listed when you're ready matters more than any town median. It's why I'd rather show you live comparables on both ends than hand you a rule of thumb.

What I won't do is tell you the market is about to move in your favour, or against it. Nobody knows that, and decisions that depend on it tend to age badly. What I can give you is a clear read on where prices and timelines actually are right now, on both sides of your move.

What working with me looks like

I've been licensed in York Region for over ten years, and I'm with RE/MAX All-Stars Realty. Most of my writing is about East Gwillimbury, which is directly south of Georgina and where I follow municipal planning and infrastructure closely. The habit carries over: I'd rather understand why a street prices the way it does than guess at it.

In practice, selling with me runs roughly like this:

  • The evaluation. A written number with the comparable sales behind it, and an honest read on what's working against you as well as for you.
  • The pricing conversation. What listing high actually costs you in days on market, and where the realistic range sits.
  • Prep. What's worth doing before you list and, more often, what isn't. Not every repair earns its money back.
  • Marketing and showings. Photography, the listing, and getting the right Buyers through the door.
  • Offers. Reading the terms, not just the number, and telling you what I'd do in your position.

If that sounds like the way you'd want this handled, the evaluation is the place to start. There's nothing to sign and nothing to pay.

Keswick and Georgina FAQ

What is my Keswick home worth?
There's no honest way to answer that from a postal code alone. A real number comes from what comparable homes in your part of Georgina have actually closed at recently, adjusted for your home's condition, lot, and finishes. Portal estimates tend to average across all of York Region, which is exactly the mistake that misprices Georgina. I'll put together a written evaluation for your address at no cost and with no obligation to list.
How much do homes sell for in Keswick and Georgina?
Across the Town of Georgina, which includes Keswick, the median sale price for all home types was $785,000 over the first eight months of 2026, on 401 sales. Detached homes averaged $818,000 across July and August. Those are municipality-wide figures from TRREB's Market Watch, so your street can sit meaningfully above or below them.
Do you work in Keswick, or only East Gwillimbury?
Both. East Gwillimbury is where I do most of my work and where I write about the market in detail, and Georgina is directly north of it. Keswick, Sutton and Jackson's Point are part of the area I serve, and Georgina closed more sales than East Gwillimbury did over the same period, so it isn't a sideline.
Should I sell before I buy, or buy before I sell?
It depends on your financing and your tolerance for carrying two properties, and anyone who answers it the same way for every owner isn't paying attention. What I can do is show you what your home is likely to sell for and how long comparable homes have been taking, so you're making that call against real numbers rather than a hunch.
What does it cost to have you evaluate my home?
Nothing, and there's no obligation to list with me afterwards. You get a written evaluation with the comparable sales it's based on. If you decide to sell, we talk about commission and marketing then. If you decide to stay put, that's a perfectly good outcome too.